Plus500 vs XTB
If you are reading this article, you are likely having trouble deciding whether Plus500 or XTB is the better Forex trading platform for you. While both platforms generally provide positive user experiences, there are some essential differences to note.
In this Plus500 or XTB broker comparison, we outline the highlights of each trading platform to help you make a more informed decision. We evaluate:
|Feature||Plus500 (visit site)||XTB (visit site)|
|CySEC, FCA, ASIC, FMA, FSB, MAS||KNF, FCA, CMB, CySEC, IFSC|
Type of Broker:
|Market Maker||Market Maker|
U.S. Clients Allowed:
Commissions / Spreads:
Features and Platforms
Traders who seek a commission-free trading environment and do not mind elevated mark-ups from an execution-only broker will feel at home at Plus500. This broker does not provide any value-added services, only maintains a below-average proprietary trading platform; on a positive note, it does offer more than 2,400 assets. In operation since 2008, 76.4% of retail traders face a loss when trading with Plus500. Founded in 2002, Poland-based XTB, which is publicly listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange, grew into one of the most reliable multi-asset brokers. Its proprietary trading platform serves manual traders; similar to Plus500, support for automated trading solutions is unavailable. As such, neither broker caters to high-growth sectors of financial markets. XTB does offer research and education, but 82% of its retail traders face a loss.
|Type of Platform:||Proprietary platform, Web-based||MetaTrader 4, Proprietary platform, Web-based|
Guaranteed Stop Loss:
Guaranteed Limit Orders:
Interest on Margin:
Asset selection is where Plus500 trumps XTB with more than 2,400 assets versus below 2,100. Forex traders have 71 currency pairs to trade at the former against just 57 at the latter. Plus500 features 26 index CFDs, and 95 ETFs, while XTB provides traders with 42 and 80+, respectively. The majority of assets remain in equity CFDs, where the 1,737 available at Plus500 trails the 1,849 offered at XTB, which also provides 25 cryptocurrency pairs against just four at Plus500. The 585 options contracts at Plus500 add hedging and diversification opportunities. While the overall asset selection remains similar in terms of the number of total assets offered, Plus500 offers more quality due to broader sector exposure.
Typical Spreads and Fees
XTB delivers a competitive edge in trading costs. Plus500 offers Forex traders a minimum spread of 0.8 pips, which is as low as 0.1 pips at XTB. The commission-free trading environment at Plus500 carries higher mark-ups, and traders can achieve better pricing at XTB, where a commission of 0.08% and lower spreads may offer an advantage. Swap rates on leveraged overnight positions apply equally. Plus500 charges a $10 monthly inactivity fee after three months versus twelve months at XTB. Plus500 does not levy a deposit fee, while XTB charges 2.00% on PayPal, Skrill, and Neteller deposits. Third-party payment processor costs exist at both, and Plus500 and XTB pass corporate actions on to clients. Overall, XTB maintains an edge for committed traders.
Security and Trust
Both brokers are publicly listed companies, Plus500 on the London Stock Exchange and XTB on the Warsaw Stock Exchange. Therefore, both comply with stringent capital requirements and provide an equally secure trading environment. The former maintains oversight from seven regulators and the latter has oversight from four. Client deposits remain segregated, negative balance protection applies, and an investor compensation fund is available for UK and EU entities. XTB earned a reputation as a trustworthy broker. While Plus500 falls into a similar category, a 2012 UK FCA fine does exist; moreover, in 2017 this broker misled investors regarding its exposure to client positions. Plus500 and XTB both earn equal marks on security, but XTB pulls ahead when it comes to trust.
Plus500 vs XTB – Verdict
Plus500 offers clients an above-average asset selection, allowing quality diversification opportunities from a marginally overpriced commission-free cost structure. Unfortunately, the proprietary trading platform lacks essential trading functionalities such as support for automated trading solutions or social trading. As an execution-only broker, advanced retail traders with access to a superior independent trading platform and research tools may benefit from the quality asset selection at Plus500. XTB provides traders with its proprietary xStation5, which is suitable for manual traders only, similar to Plus500. It grants fewer assets but a more competitive cost structure. While Plus500 neither provides research nor adequate education, XTB delivers a quality service for both. New traders have five educational categories that consist of numerous lessons; while it remains notably superior to Plus500, it is not as extensive as other well-established competitors. The research and market commentary provide a competitive service for all traders to consider. Given the similarities between both brokers, XTB pulls ahead due to its cost structure, research, and educational capabilities.
Does Plus500 or XTB offer lower pricing?
The pricing environment remains lower at XTB, which offers Forex traders a minimum spread of 0.1 pips and charges at least 0.08% in commissions on equity CFDs. While Plus500 deploys a commission-free structure, the minimum mark-up on currency pairs is 0.8 pips, and equities carry above-average spreads to cover the absence of commissions. The final advantage remains asset dependent.
Which is the more reliable broker?
Both brokers earned a reputation for reliability. Plus500 is a publicly listed company on the London Stock Exchange and is also a constituent of the FTSE 250 index. XTB is listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange. Traders at either Plus500 or XTB will trade with a well-capitalized broker and under an excellent global regulatory environment. XTB has a clean track record, while at least two missteps remain part of the Plus500 history, one a regulatory fine.
What about MetaTrader and copy trading?
Neither Plus500 nor XTB provide traders with the MT4/MT5 trading platforms. Both opted for their proprietary trading platforms, which lack support for automated trading solutions and copy trading. Only manual traders will find the available alternatives suitable, as Plus500 and XTB ignore the two fastest-growing sectors of the financial system.
What are the minimum deposits for these brokers?
Accessibility to any trading environment is essential, and Plus500 maintains a minimum initial deposit requirement of $100. Additional deposits may be less than $100 and will be dependent on the payment processors. XTB opted for no minimums, granting all traders complete control over how they build their portfolio. A word of caution; traders should refrain from micro-transactions, as third-party fees can add up substantially over time.