Nadex versus Robinhood

Nadex offers US binary options traders a domestic champion and unrivaled trading conditions. Founded in 2004 and built-up to its current form under IG Markets leadership, who sold the company to Crypto.com in 2022, traders get low-cost binary options, call spreads, and knockouts, from an exceptional management team.

Robinhood is one of the pioneers of commission-free trading in the US but has a questionable operational track record and supplements income with payment for order flow. It experienced explosive growth from 2020 through 2021 amid heightened controversy and criticism before losing clients. Traders at both brokers get a proprietary web-based trading platform and user-friendly mobile app.

We have conducted an in-depth review of Nadex and Robinhood to determine which one presents the better overall choice and which traders will benefit the most at either broker.

Features and Platforms

Features & PlatformsNadex (visit site)Robinhood (visit site)
Headquarter:USUS
Established :
20042013
Retail Loss Rate:
UndisclosedUndisclosed
Regulation:
Minimum Deposit:
$250$0
Demo Account:
Managed Account:
Islamic Account:
Inactivity Fee
$10 monthly after 12 monthsNo
Deposit Fee:
Third-PartyNo
Withdrawal Fee
Yes + Third-PartyThird-Party
Funding Methods:
22
MT4:
MT5:
cTrader:
Proprietary Platform:
Automated Trading:
Social / Copy Trading:
MT4/MT5 Add-ons:
Guaranteed Stop Loss:
Negative Balance Protection:
Bonuses and Promotions:
Unique Feature One:
User-friendly mobile appAccess to IPOs
Unique Feature Two:
Fixed trading costsFractional share trading
Broker Offers:

Noteworthy:

Neither Nadex nor Robinhood offer algorithmic trading, both cater primarily to beginner traders with a preference for mobile trading, and Robinhood features a branded debit card with weekly rewards.

Available Markets

Available MarketsNadexRobinhood
Currency Pairs:
Cryptocurrency Pairs:
Commodities and Metals:
Indices:
Equities:
Bonds:
ETFs:
Options, Futures, and Synthetics:
Maximum Retail Leverage:
1:11:2
Maximum Pro Leverage:
1:11:2

The asset selection at Nadex remains limited in trading instruments but features dozens of expiry times. Traders get liquid assets, supporting focused trading strategies. Robinhood features a broader asset selection consisting of equities, ETFs, IPOs, options, gold, and select cryptocurrencies, offering better cross-asset diversification, but Nadex caters better to its core trader base.

Typical Spreads and Fees

Typical Spreads & FeesNadexRobinhood
Minimum Raw Spreads:
Not applicableNot applicable
Minimum Standard Spreads:
UndisclosedNot applicable
Minimum Commission for Forex:
$1 per contractNot applicable
Commission for Equities:
Not applicableCommission-free
Commission Rebates:
NoNot applicable
Execution Type:
Market MakerMarket Maker

Nadex offers binary options traders minimum tick values of $0.25 per spot Forex contract, $1.00 for knock-out options, and $1.00 for call spread contracts, plus a fee of $1.00 per contract. Robinhood has issues with trading cost transparency. While it advertises commission-free trading, it engages in controversial payment for order flow.

Security and Trust

Nadex

Country of the RegulatorName of the RegulatorLicense Number
US
Commodity Futures Trading Commission & National Futures AssociationNFA Number 0340344

Robinhood

Country of the RegulatorName of the RegulatorLicense Number
US
US Securities and Exchange CommissionUndisclosed

Nadex has a spotless NFA record and outstanding corporate management with an equally impressive history. Both brokers segregate client deposits from corporate funds. Robinhood is also a Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), The New York Stock Exchange (NYSE), the NASDAQ, and the CBOE EDGX Exchange (CBOE EDGX) member. The Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC) protects Robinhood clients up to $500,000 per net equity or $250,000 for cash claims. Traders should consider the controversy at Robinhood in the light of the excellent history at Nadex.

Nadex vs Robinhood – Verdict

Nadex

ProsCons
User-friendly mobile appLimited deposit and withdrawal options
Educational content for beginner tradersLimited choice of trading instruments
Trustworthy reputation now under the corporate ownership of Crypto.comAlgorithmic trading unavailable
Low trading costs for an options broker

Robinhood

ProsCons
Fractional share dealing from $1.00 and access to IPO trading Limited deposit and withdrawal options
Debit card for swift financial transactions with weekly rewardsQuestionable business practices and lack of overall transparency
Beginner traders get a wealth of educational content in written formAlgorithmic trading not available/i>
Optimized mobile app

Neither broker offers traders the MT4 trading platform or supports algorithmic trading, but both provide their proprietary trading platforms and mobile apps. Trading costs at Nadex are cheaper, while Robinhood offers fractional share dealing ideal for smaller portfolios. Nadex trumps Robinhood with a more trustworthy trading environment and notably better management.

You might also be interested in reviewing the below broker comparisons:

Read full Nadex Review

Most Visited Forex Broker Reviews