Interactive Brokers vs. TradeStation
If you are reading this article, you’re likely having trouble deciding whether TradeStation or Interactive Brokers is the better Forex trading platform for you. While both platforms generally provide positive user experiences, there are some essential differences to note.
In this Interactive Brokers vs. TradeStation review, we outline the highlights of each trading platform to help you make a more informed decision. We evaluate:
|Feature||TradeStation (visit site)||Interactive Brokers (visit site)|
|FINRA||SIPC, SEC, FINRA|
Type of Broker:
|Market Maker,ECN/STP||Market Maker|
U.S. Clients Allowed:
|$10,000, $5,000 for an IRA|
Commissions / Spreads:
|Both||Fixed, Volume Tiered|
|M - F, 08:00 am - 08:00 pm||24/6|
Features and Platforms
TradeStation enjoys continued growth behind its innovative proprietary trading platform, supported by its Trading App Store. While it remains competitive, it cannot compete with Interactive Brokers, which presents a superior proprietary trading platform, and its Investor’s Marketplace features 1,500+ services. Both brokers support algorithmic trading and offer quality education to beginner traders. Interactive Brokers takes the lead with its extensive research. Cryptocurrency traders may earn up to 6% annual interest on eligible cryptocurrency assets at TradeStation. The core trading environment at both brokers presents identical features, with Interactive Brokers on top.
|Type of Platform:||Proprietary platform||Web-based, Other|
Guaranteed Stop Loss:
Guaranteed Limit Orders:
Interest on Margin:
Clients at TradeStation have access to stocks, ETFs, IPOs, options, futures, futures options, cryptocurrencies, mutual funds, and bonds. One asset class notably missing is Forex trading. Therefore, TradeStation is a choice for equity portfolios and cryptocurrency investors. Interactive Brokers presents investors and traders with 135 markets across 33 countries in 23 currencies, one of the most in-depth choices of trading instruments industry wide. Neither broker maintains a detailed asset list, but TradeStation and Interactive Brokers offer clients a well-balanced choice of available markets. Interactive Brokers trumps TradeStation, as the overall asset selection beats in quantity and quality.
Typical Spreads and Fees
Equity and ETF trading in the TradeStation TS Select account remains commission-free. Stock options fees are $0.60 per contract, futures and micro futures $1.50 and $0.50 per side, respectively, and futures options $1.50. Traders in the TS Go pay an extra $10.00 fee for stocks and options and $1.40 for futures trading. Interactive Brokers features one of the best commission-based cost structures. Forex traders pay a spread of 0.1 pips for a commission of $2.00 per order or $3.00 per lot, and equity traders a commission of 0.05%. Margin trading also remains cheaper at Interactive Brokers.
Security and Trust
The ultimate regulator of TradeStation and Interactive Brokers is the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Both brokers are also members of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), the self-regulatory organization with SEC oversight. Interactive Brokers also has oversight from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and trusted international regulators. The Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC) protects clients up to $500,000 per net equity or $250,000 for cash claims at both. TradeStation owner Monex Group is a publicly listed company in Japan, while Interactive Brokers remains listed in the US. Both brokers remain equally secure and trustworthy.
TradeStation vs Interactive Brokers – Verdict
Both brokers present investors and traders with an excellent core trading environment and the ultimate decision concerning the better choice between TradeStation and Interactive Brokers boils down to individual preferences. While similarities exist, Interactive Brokers trumps TradeStation across the board. Its proprietary trading platform and Investor’s Marketplace remain superior to TradeStation and its Trading App Store. The asset selection and trading costs are competitive at both, while Interactive Brokers pulls ahead once again. Quality market research and an excellent educational platform are available at TradeStation and Interactive Brokers alike, but the latter also maintains managed portfolios. The owner of TradeStation, Japanese financial behemoth Monex Group, is a publicly listed company in Japan, and Interactive Brokers is a US-listed company on the NASDAQ. Both maintain an equally secure and trustworthy trading environment. Active traders, especially those requiring margin portfolios, receive better overall trading conditions at Interactive Brokers.
Which is better: TradeStation or Interactive Brokers?
Both brokers present clients with a competitive trading environment, but Interactive Brokers bests TradeStation across the board in the quantity and quality of its product and services portfolio.
Is TradeStation and Interactive Brokers the same?
TradeStation and Interactive Brokers are not the same company but compete in the same industry. Both brokers continue to increase their market share.
How much does TradeStation cost a month?
The monthly trading costs depend on the requirements of the individual. There are numerous costs for market data packages, with discounts for active traders. Not all traders require them, and most retail traders will pay no monthly fees.
Is TradeStation good for day trading?
TradeStation presents a competitive trading environment well-suited for day trading for US-based traders.
Who is the best trading platform?
Between TradeStation and Interactive Brokers, the best trading platform is available at the latter.