eToro vs Trading 212
This Forex broker comparison will take a deeper look at eToro, a social trading platform operational since 2007 and home to over 3,000,000 traders, and Trading 212, a mostly-mobile trading platform which is highly popular in the UK and Germany. It introduced zero-commission trading, and the application has been downloaded over 14 million times in a statement to its popularity. The former compensates for its services with excessive fees, while the latter offers traders tight spreads in a competitive trading environment. eToro markets itself as a FinTech company, but Trading 212 displays its strength as one, evident by the products provided.
This comparison will focus on the following four aspects plus an ultimate verdict:
|Feature||eToro (visit site)||Trading 212 (visit site)|
|CySEC, FCA, ASIC||FCA, FSCS|
Type of Broker:
|Market Maker||Market Maker|
U.S. Clients Allowed:
|$50 - $10,000||£10 or a currency equivalent|
|1:30 (CySEC, FCA), 1:500 (ASIC)||1:30|
Commissions / Spreads:
68% of retail CFD accounts lose money
Features and Platforms
Social trading has retreated from its peak, but eToro attempts to present a suitable option to those interested in following other traders. This broker continues to push forward with success, as evidenced by millions of active traders using the in-house developed CopyTrader. The addition of CopyPortfolios was an attempt to decrease risk and add more diversification to investment opportunities. The trading platform is available as a webtrader and mobile version. In the course of this comparison, we discovered that that TipRanks, a third-party provider where traders may access market coverage provided by over 15,000 analysts is perhaps the best feature offered by eToro.
The ProCharts charting package enhances manual trading. eToro also buys and holds select physical assets for clients, and the Popular Investor Program offers qualified signal providers an annualized compensation of 2% of allocated assets. With social trading at the core of operations, the in-house research and education remains secondary and of lesser quality.
The 66.0% loss rate of traders ranks eToro ahead of many competitors, essential to the success of its business model.
eToro advances social trading successfully, but its fees are higher than most brokers.
Commission-free trading is gaining popularity, disrupting traditional brokerage models, and Trading 212 remains one of the pioneers of this trend.This FinTech company operates out of the UK and Bulgaria, offering two distinct account types. The CFD account is for leveraged trading, and the Invest account offers traditional equity trading. Adding to the innovative services is fractional share trading, allowing traders with less substantial capital to manage a well-diversified portfolio.
Another great feature is ProQuant. It allows the creation of automated trading robots without the need to code. Daily analytics are provided, but the quality is sub-standard, with the risk warning more detailed than the analysis. Education is offered through well-presented video content, granting an excellent introduction for new traders with a modern approach. The overall trading conditions are outstanding, but 76% of retail traders operate their portfolios at a loss when trading with Trading 212, a full 10 percent more than eToro’s losses.
Trading 212 offers traders an innovative suite of trading options.
|Type of Platform:||Proprietary platform||Proprietary platform|
Guaranteed Stop Loss:
Interest on Margin:
eToro features more than 2,000 assets across six categories. With forty-seven currency pairs and seventeen cryptocurrency pairs, Forex traders can easily diversify their core portfolios. Through thirteen commodities, an additional diversification opportunity is presented. Another thirteen index CFDs and 145 ETFs offer trading opportunities with the remainder of assets spread across global equities. Trading 212 offers a superior asset selection with over 3,000 across the same six categories.
Pure Forex traders have access to over 185 currency and cryptocurrency pairs, with an additional 23 commodities. The outstanding equity selection is complemented by 44 index and ETF CFDs. Both brokers offer an asset selection suitable for the majority of traders.
Typical Spreads and Fees
The pricing environment at eToro remains unacceptably elevated, with the lowest spread listed as 3.0 pips for the EUR/USD. While zero commission equity trades are marketed, they solely apply to buy orders in non-leveraged portfolios. Leveraged portfolios and short-sellers are levied with a 0.09% fee. In comparison, Trading 212 offers the EUR/USD as low a 0.8 pips without additional costs together with free equity trades, generating a superior pricing environment. The former attempts to cover expenses for its social trading service with tremendous mark-ups, while the latter achieves a trader-friendly composition for manual and automated traders. On the other hand, eToro’s traders may be willing to pay the higher fees for the opportunity to copy experienced traders and hopefully to enjoy fewer losses than are seen with Trading 212.
Swap rates on leveraged overnight positions are equally applied. Since eToro and Trading 212 feature a sound equity selection, corporate actions like dividends and mergers are passed onto traders. eToro charges a $5 flat-fee on all withdrawals, where Trading 212 remains free of charges. Third-party costs may apply, depending on the payment processor utilized. The broad pricing environment remains significantly more geared towards trader profitability at Trading 212, and towards broker profitability at eToro.
Equity trading is advertised as commission-free, but the fine print reveals extreme limitations.
Trading 212 offers one of the most competitive pricing structures available in today’s competitive brokerage industry.
Security and Trust
The Cyprus Securities and Exchange Commission (CySEC) provides a regulatory framework for eToro under MiFID II and the EU’s 5th Anti-Money Laundering Directive. The UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) and the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) provide additional regulation. Client funds are protected by the Investor Compensation Fund (CIF) in Cyprus up to a maximum of €20,000, applicable to eToro Europe traders, and the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) up to £85,000 for clients of eToro UK. eToro USA LLC, registered with FinCEN as a Money Services Business, is where US-based traders have access to this broker.
Trading 212 also holds regulation in several jurisdictions, where traders can manage portfolios in a secure trading environment. Trading 212 UK LTD operates under the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) framework, and Trading 212 LTD is authorized by the Bulgarian Financial Supervision Commission. The Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) protects client deposits from the former. The Bulgarian Investors Compensation Fund those of the latter up to 90% of deposits, with a maximum of €20,000. Client funds at both brokers remain fully segregated, and traders are provided with a trustworthy trading environment by eToro and Trading 212 alike.
Four distinct regulatory jurisdictions create a secure trading environment at eToro.
Trading 212 is a compliant and trustworthy broker with a regulatory environment in two jurisdictions.
eToro vs Trading 212 - Verdict
eToro presents itself as an exceptional brokerage with operational statistics supporting claims of a market-leader position in social trading. It claims that as of June 2018, 73% of 124 million copied trades have been profitable. While social trading opportunities remain outstanding based on choice, the fees levied by give Trading 212 a significant advantage in this area. Trading 212 is a broker operated by a fintech company, disrupting the brokerage industry with commission-free trading, targeting millennial traders on the move. The low-cost trading environment is visible in the absence of proper research capabilities.
It is partially offset by ProQuant, allowing traders to develop automated solutions without the need to code. Social trading remains the core business of eToro. Through ProQuant, a more profitable and automated trading strategy can be deployed, at Trading 212. Inexperienced traders will likely find more success by following eToro’s pro traders, but their gains will be offset with higher fees. Experienced traders will appreciate Trading 212’s commission-free fee structure more than the benefits offered by eToro. Likewise, it is important to note that only eToro offers trading to U.S. traders, which makes them the obvious choice for U.S. residents.
Which is the more reliable broker?
While eToro has more regulators providing oversight, Trading 212 maintains an equally trustworthy and reliable trading environment. eToro claims over 13,000,000 traders and Trading 212 more than 15,000,000 platform downloads. Both execute their business strategy well and continue to expand their market share. From a reliability standpoint, both remain on par with each other.
Which is better, eToro or Trading 212?
eToro maintains an edge in social trading, its core market sector, but Trading 212 presents traders with an overall more sophisticated product and services portfolio. The quality of the trading platform, cost structure, and asset selection at Trading 212 significantly outstrips what eToro offers traders. The gap widens with the addition of AutoInvest & Pies at Trading 212, catering to automated trading solutions, which eToro does not support.
Which broker is better for beginner traders?
It depends on the intentions of the individual trader. Those seeking to copy others with a few clicks will find what eToro provides superior. Trading 212 maintains an edge across all other categories, including education. Neither broker offers the MT4 trading platform, but the proprietary alternative at Trading 212 is of higher quality, making it the better broker for beginner traders.
What are the minimum deposits for these brokers?
Most traders at eToro have a minimum deposit requirement of $50, while select jurisdictions carry a higher one. Trading 212 asks for just $10 or a currency equivalent, granting traders more flexibility to implement a portfolio growth strategy. It also makes Trading 212 accessible to a broader range of traders, but eToro is not far behind.